Small Butt Plugs

Whether you're dipping your toes into anal play or whether you've found your perfect size and want something new, our collection of small butt plugs is sure to have something that will catch your eye. Scroll through and find a new favorite, and if you're looking to make clean-up or prep a bit easier, check our toy cleaner or enema and douches categories.

Small Anal Plugs

Refine

107 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Booty Call Petite Probe Black California Exotic Novelties Anal Toys
Booty Call Petite Probe Black
Regular Price
$ 16.99
Sale Price
$ 16.99
Regular Price
$ 16.99
Unit Price
per 
Emojibator Orville Anal Vibe
Regular Price
$ 51.99
Sale Price
$ 51.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Avant Free Spirit Scarlet
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
NEW
Save 30%
Ripple Small Midnight Purple
Regular Price
$ 25.99
Sale Price
$ 25.99
Regular Price
$ 36.99
Unit Price
per 
Fantasy For Her Her Little Gems Small Plug
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Sale Price
$ 19.99
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Unit Price
per 
Open Roses by Love to Love Plug Small - Purple Rain
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
Evolved Joy Sticks
Regular Price
$ 71.99
Sale Price
$ 71.99
Regular Price
$ 71.99
Unit Price
per 
Gender X Gold Digger Small
Regular Price
$ 29.99
Sale Price
$ 29.99
Regular Price
$ 29.99
Unit Price
per 
njoy Pure Plug Small
Regular Price
$ 68.99
Sale Price
$ 68.99
Regular Price
$ 68.99
Unit Price
per 
njoy Prostate Pfun Plug
Regular Price
$ 99.99
Sale Price
$ 99.99
Regular Price
$ 99.99
Unit Price
per 
Avant Kaleido Lime
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Unit Price
per 
Avant Twilight Blue
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Unit Price
per 
Fun Factory Bootie Plug - Small - Black
Regular Price
$ 36.99
Sale Price
$ 36.99
Regular Price
$ 36.99
Unit Price
per 
VeDO Rio Anal Vibe - Black
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Sale Price
$ 32.99
Regular Price
$ 28.99
Unit Price
per 
Rocks Off Petite Sensations Teazer - Purple
Regular Price
$ 28.99
Sale Price
$ 28.99
Regular Price
$ 28.99
Unit Price
per 
Rocks Off Petite Sensations Smooth Plug - Purple
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Unit Price
per 
LoveLife Dare Curved Plug
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Unit Price
per 
LoveLife Explore Pleasure Plug
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-31 Plug Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-31 Plug Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-10 Plug-Pull Ring Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-10 Plug-Pull Ring Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-78 Pointee Plug Red Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-78 Pointee Plug Black Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-63 Rattler Spade Red Small
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Sale Price
$ 23.99
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-63 Rattler Spade Black Small
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Sale Price
$ 23.99
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-60 Spade Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-60 Spade Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-11 Lungo Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-11 Lungo Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Unit Price
per 

Frequently Asked Questions

Blog posts

Do Men Use Sex Toys? Time to Deconstruct That Thought and Enjoy True Pleasure

Do Men Use Sex Toys? Time to Deconstruct That Thought and Enjoy True Pleasure

At the risk of jumping straight to the conclusion, the answer is yes – men use sex toys...
Read More
The 5 Best Christmas Ideas - For Her

The 5 Best Christmas Ideas - For Her

      Shopping for the holidays is always stressful. Between trying to remember the t...
Read More
The Benefits of Sex Toys for Your Relationship

The Benefits of Sex Toys for Your Relationship

   Table of Contents Introduction Bringing Up the Subject Phrasing and Conversatio...
Read More