Small Butt Plugs

Whether you're dipping your toes into anal play or whether you've found your perfect size and want something new, our collection of small butt plugs is sure to have something that will catch your eye. Scroll through and find a new favorite, and if you're looking to make clean-up or prep a bit easier, check our toy cleaner or enema and douches categories.

Small Anal Plugs

Refine

134 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Save 51%
Perfect Plug Plus Purple
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Sale Price
$ 39.99
Regular Price
$ 80.99
Unit Price
per 
Squeeze-it Silexpan Anal Plug Small Black XR Brands Anal Toys
Squeeze-it Silexpan Anal Plug Small Black
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Sale Price
$ 32.99
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Pretty Love Vibrating Special Stimulation Butt Plug Pretty Love Anal Toys
Pretty Love Vibrating Special Stimulation Butt Plug
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Booty Call Petite Probe Black California Exotic Novelties Anal Toys
Booty Call Petite Probe Black
Regular Price
$ 16.99
Sale Price
$ 16.99
Regular Price
$ 16.99
Unit Price
per 
Mystim Rocking Force Small
Regular Price
$ 73.99
Sale Price
$ 73.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
VeDO Rio Anal Vibe - Indigo
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Sale Price
$ 32.99
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Unit Price
per 
Rear Assets Small Pink
Regular Price
$ 15.99
Sale Price
$ 15.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Crystal Flower Black
Regular Price
$ 35.99
Sale Price
$ 35.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Booty Sparks Silicone Light-up Anal Plug Small
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Booty Sparks Silicone Light-up Anal Plug Medium
Regular Price
$ 34.99
Sale Price
$ 34.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Temptasia Bling Plug Small Black Blush Novelties Anal Toys
Temptasia Bling Plug Small Black
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Sale Price
$ 19.99
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Unit Price
per 
Sensuelle Mini Butt Plug Purple Nu Sensuelle Anal Toys
Sensuelle Mini Butt Plug Purple
Regular Price
$ 58.99
Sale Price
$ 58.99
Regular Price
$ 56.99
Unit Price
per 
Playboy Tux Small
Regular Price
$ 29.99
Sale Price
$ 29.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Perfect Plug Purple
Regular Price
$ 27.99
Sale Price
$ 27.99
Regular Price
$ 27.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Perfect Plug Plus Black
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Sale Price
$ 39.99
Regular Price
$ 80.99
Unit Price
per 
Perfect Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 27.99
Sale Price
$ 27.99
Regular Price
$ 27.99
Unit Price
per 
Naughty Bits Shake Your Ass Petite Vibrating Butt Plug California Exotic Novelties Anal Toys
Naughty Bits Shake Your Ass Petite Vibrating Butt Plug
Regular Price
$ 50.99
Sale Price
$ 50.99
Regular Price
$ 50.99
Unit Price
per 
NEW
Gvibe Gplug XS - Sunny Raspberry
Regular Price
$ 38.99
Sale Price
$ 38.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Little Flirt Black
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Sale Price
$ 31.99
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Unit Price
per 
Little Flirt Purple
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Glowhole-1 Buttplug W- Led Insert Small Clear Frost OXBALLS Anal Toys
Glowhole-1 Buttplug W- Led Insert Small Clear Frost
Regular Price
$ 86.99
Sale Price
$ 86.99
Regular Price
$ 86.99
Unit Price
per 
Booty Sparks Glow-in-the-dark Glass Anal Plug Small XR Brands Anal Toys
Booty Sparks Glow-in-the-dark Glass Anal Plug Small
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Gender X Electric Blue
Regular Price
$ 71.99
Sale Price
$ 71.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
B-Vibe Snug Plug 1 (S) - Violet
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Sale Price
$ 47.99
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Unit Price
per 
Anal Fantasy Vibrating Butt Buddy Pipedream Products Anal Toys
Anal Fantasy Vibrating Butt Buddy
Regular Price
$ 33.99
Sale Price
$ 33.99
Regular Price
$ 33.99
Unit Price
per 
B-Vibe Snug Plug 1 (S) - Mint
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Sale Price
$ 47.99
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Unit Price
per 
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibra Slim Plug Small Black Blush Novelties Anal Toys
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibra Slim Plug Small Black
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Unit Price
per 
Naughty Candy Heart Spank Me Yellow Blush Novelties Gag Gifts
Naughty Candy Heart Spank Me Yellow
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Naughty Candy Heart Do Me Now Purple Blush Novelties Gag Gifts
Naughty Candy Heart Do Me Now Purple
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Naughty Candy Heart Be Mine Pink Blush Novelties Gag Gifts
Naughty Candy Heart Be Mine Pink
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Frequently Asked Questions

Lets Talk about Sex

My Favorite Toys by Dame Products

My Favorite Toys by Dame Products

Dame is a constantly progressing company that I instantly felt a cosmic calling towards...
Read More
Everything You Need to Know About Air Pulse Toys

Everything You Need to Know About Air Pulse Toys

Air pulsation toys, also known as air pressure or suction toys, have gained popula...
Read More
My Impression of the Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit

My Impression of the Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit

The Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit is a toy I typically would not gravitate toward. I...
Read More