Small Butt Plugs

Whether you're dipping your toes into anal play, or whether you've found your perfect size and just want something new, our collection of small butt plugs are sure to have something that will catch your eye. Scroll through and find a new favorite, and if you're looking to make clean-up or prep a bit easier as well, make sure to check our toy cleaner or enema and douches categories.

Small Anal Plugs

Refine

97 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Booty Call Petite Probe Black California Exotic Novelties Anal Toys
Booty Call Petite Probe Black
Regular Price
$ 16.99
Sale Price
$ 16.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Happy Rabbit Butt Plug Black-Purple Tail Small Rechargeable
Regular Price
$ 64.99
Sale Price
$ 64.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Fun Factory Bootie Plug - Small - Black
Regular Price
$ 36.99
Sale Price
$ 36.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
VeDO Rio Anal Vibe - Black
Regular Price
$ 28.99
Sale Price
$ 28.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Rocks Off Petite Sensations Teazer - Purple
Regular Price
$ 28.99
Sale Price
$ 28.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Rocks Off Petite Sensations Smooth Plug - Purple
Rocks Off Petite Sensations Smooth Plug - Purple
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
LoveLife Dare Curved Plug
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
LoveLife Explore Pleasure Plug
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-31 Plug Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-10 Plug-Pull Ring Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-10 Plug-Pull Ring Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-78 Pointee Plug Red Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-78 Pointee Plug Black Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-63 Rattler Spade Red Small
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Sale Price
$ 23.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-63 Rattler Spade Black Small
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Sale Price
$ 23.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-60 Spade Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-60 Spade Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-11 Lungo Red Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-11 Lungo Black Small
Regular Price
$ 20.99
Sale Price
$ 20.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-21 TearDrop Red Small
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-21 TearDrop Black Small
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-98 Cone Red Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-98 Cone Black Small
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-30 Pointer Red Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-30 Pointer Black Small
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Gvibe Gplug Small - Navy Blue
Regular Price
$ 62.99
Sale Price
$ 62.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Gvibe Gplug Small - Neon Rose
Regular Price
$ 62.99
Sale Price
$ 62.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Fun Factory Bootie Plug - Small - Violet
Regular Price
$ 36.99
Sale Price
$ 36.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
B-Vibe Vibrating Snug Plug 1 (S) - Orange
Regular Price
$ 109.99
Sale Price
$ 109.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Crystal Delights Funfetti Plug - Aurora Borealis
Regular Price
$ 44.99
Sale Price
$ 44.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Blog posts

Tenga Flip Hole: Literally Everything You Need To Know!

Tenga Flip Hole: Literally Everything You Need To Know!

Are you looking to spice things up in the bedroom? Are you bored of masturbating using ...
Read More
Pheromone Fragrances: TikTok's Newest Obsession

Pheromone Fragrances: TikTok's Newest Obsession

Back in December, TikTok found another thing to blow up in popularity, introducing mill...
Read More
101 Funny Slang Words for Penis

101 Funny Slang Words for Penis

We've heard a lot of terms for "The Penis" but I've compiled a list of 101 of our absolute favorite synonyms for the Male Genitalia. You have heard some of these slang names but probably not all.

Read More