Medium Butt Plugs

Whether you're sizing up from a smaller plug or whether you've found your perfect size and want something new, our collection of medium butt plugs is sure to have something that will catch your eye. Scroll through and find a new favorite, and if you're looking to make clean-up or prep a bit easier, check our toy cleaner or enema and douches categories.

Medium Anal Plugs

Refine

114 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Expandable Butt Plug California Exotic Novelties Anal Toys
Expandable Butt Plug
Regular Price
$ 34.99
Sale Price
$ 34.99
Regular Price
$ 32.99
Unit Price
per 
Amethyst Rain Butt Plug Electric / Hustler Lingerie Anal Toys
Glas Amethyst Rain Butt Plug
Regular Price
$ 27.99
Sale Price
$ 27.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Pretty Love Vibrating Bulb Pretty Love Anal Toys
Pretty Love Vibrating Bulb
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Silicone Inflatable Plug Medium
Regular Price
$ 44.99
Sale Price
$ 44.99
Regular Price
$ 44.99
Unit Price
per 
Booty Sparks Weighted Blue Gem Anal Plug Medium XR Brands Anal Toys
Booty Sparks Weighted Blue Gem Anal Plug Medium
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug XR Brands Anal Toys
Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Sensuelle R-c Mini Plug Black Nu Sensuelle Anal Toys
Sensuelle R-c Mini Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Sale Price
$ 94.99
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Unit Price
per 
Glas Glass Butt Plug 3.5 " Electric / Hustler Lingerie Anal Toys
Glas Glass Butt Plug 3.5 "
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Glas 5 Rosebud Glass Butt Plug " Electric / Hustler Lingerie Anal Toys
Glas 5 Rosebud Glass Butt Plug
Regular Price
$ 40.99
Sale Price
$ 40.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Cute Little Fuckers Princette Puppypus - Purple
Regular Price
$ 61.99
Sale Price
$ 61.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Cute Little Fuckers Princette Puppypus - Platinum
Regular Price
$ 61.99
Sale Price
$ 61.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Squeeze-it Silexpan Anal Plug Medium Black XR Brands Anal Toys
Squeeze-it Silexpan Anal Plug Medium Black
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Sale Price
$ 39.99
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Unit Price
per 
SOLD OUT
Severin Medium Super Soft Copper
Regular Price
$ 45.99
Sale Price
$ 45.99
Regular Price
$ 45.99
Unit Price
per 
Neo Black
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Sale Price
$ 31.99
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Unit Price
per 
Icicles # 79
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Sale Price
$ 39.99
Regular Price
$ 39.99
Unit Price
per 
Gender X Rockin Metal Plug
Regular Price
$ 75.99
Sale Price
$ 75.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
B-Vibe Snug Plug 2 (M) - Green
Regular Price
$ 51.99
Sale Price
$ 51.99
Regular Price
$ 51.99
Unit Price
per 
B-Vibe Snug Plug 2 (M) - Coral
Regular Price
$ 51.99
Sale Price
$ 51.99
Regular Price
$ 51.99
Unit Price
per 
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Stout Plug Medium Black Blush Novelties Anal Toys
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Stout Plug Medium Black
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Anal Adventures Orb Plug Black Blush Novelties Anal Toys
Anal Adventures Orb Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Sale Price
$ 19.99
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Unit Price
per 
Vedo Twist Rechargeable Anal Plug Deep Purple
Regular Price
$ 55.99
Sale Price
$ 55.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Playboy Spinning Tail Teaser
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Sale Price
$ 94.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Playboy Plug & Play
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Sale Price
$ 94.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
NEW
Fun Factory Bootie Fem Plug - Rose
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Sale Price
$ 47.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
NEW
B-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug Medium/Large - Scarlet Ruby
Regular Price
$ 127.99
Sale Price
$ 127.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
NEW
Fun Factory Bootie Fem Plug - Dark Taupe
Regular Price
$ 47.99
Sale Price
$ 47.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
NEW
B-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug Small/Medium - Pink Topaz
Regular Price
$ 127.99
Sale Price
$ 127.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Vedo Twist Rechargeable Anal Plug Black Pearl
Regular Price
$ 55.99
Sale Price
$ 55.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Vedo Plug Rechargeable Anal Plug Deep Purple
Regular Price
$ 55.99
Sale Price
$ 55.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Vedo Plug Rechargeable Anal Plug Black Pearl
Regular Price
$ 55.99
Sale Price
$ 55.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 

Frequently Asked Questions

Lets Talk about Sex

My Favorite Toys by Dame Products

My Favorite Toys by Dame Products

Dame is a constantly progressing company that I instantly felt a cosmic calling towards...
Read More
Everything You Need to Know About Air Pulse Toys

Everything You Need to Know About Air Pulse Toys

Air pulsation toys, also known as air pressure or suction toys, have gained popula...
Read More
My Impression of the Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit

My Impression of the Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit

The Viben Dazzle Suction Rabbit is a toy I typically would not gravitate toward. I...
Read More