Medium Butt Plugs

Whether you're sizing up from a smaller plug or whether you've found your perfect size and want something new, our collection of medium butt plugs is sure to have something that will catch your eye. Scroll through and find a new favorite, and if you're looking to make clean-up or prep a bit easier, check our toy cleaner or enema and douches categories.

Medium Anal Plugs

Refine

86 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Pretty Love Vibrating Bulb Pretty Love Anal Toys
Pretty Love Vibrating Bulb
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Booty Sparks Weighted Blue Gem Anal Plug Medium XR Brands Anal Toys
Booty Sparks Weighted Blue Gem Anal Plug Medium
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug XR Brands Anal Toys
Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
Sensuelle R-c Mini Plug Black Nu Sensuelle Anal Toys
Sensuelle R-c Mini Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Sale Price
$ 94.99
Regular Price
$ 94.99
Unit Price
per 
Glas Glass Butt Plug 3.5 " Electric / Hustler Lingerie Anal Toys
Glas Glass Butt Plug 3.5 "
Regular Price
$ 24.99
Sale Price
$ 24.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Neo Purple
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Sale Price
$ 31.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Avant Free Spirit Scarlet
Regular Price
$ 30.99
Sale Price
$ 30.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Gender X Just The Tip
Regular Price
$ 41.99
Sale Price
$ 41.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Fantasy For Her Her Little Gems Medium Plug
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Unit Price
per 
Open Roses by Love to Love Plug Medium - Plum Star
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-60 Spade Black Medium
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
Gender X Gold Digger Medium
Regular Price
$ 31.99
Sale Price
$ 31.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
njoy Pure Plug Medium
Regular Price
$ 78.99
Sale Price
$ 78.99
Regular Price
$ 78.99
Unit Price
per 
Cheeky Medium Tie Dye Plug
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Sale Price
$ 21.99
Regular Price
$ 21.99
Unit Price
per 
Crystal Delights Sparkle Plug - Clear
Regular Price
$ 52.99
Sale Price
$ 52.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Crystal Delights Sparkle Plug - Aurora Borealis
Regular Price
$ 52.99
Sale Price
$ 52.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
B Swish Bfilled Basic Plus Wave - Seafoam
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
B Swish Bfilled Basic PLUS - Slate
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
B Swish Bfilled Basic PLUS - Magenta
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
B Swish Bfilled Basic - Orchid
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Sale Price
$ 19.99
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Unit Price
per 
B Swish Bfilled Basic - Slate
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Sale Price
$ 19.99
Regular Price
$ 19.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-36 T-Plug Red
Regular Price
$ 25.99
Sale Price
$ 25.99
Regular Price
$ 25.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-36 T-Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 25.99
Sale Price
$ 25.99
Regular Price
$ 25.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-31 Plug Red Medium
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-31 Plug Black Medium
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Sale Price
$ 22.99
Regular Price
$ 22.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-19 Plug Red
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-19 Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-83 Spir Plug Red
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-83 Spir Plug Black
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Sale Price
$ 26.99
Regular Price
$ 26.99
Unit Price
per 
FORTO F-10 Plug-Pull Ring Red Medium
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Sale Price
$ 23.99
Regular Price
$ 23.99
Unit Price
per 

Frequently Asked Questions

Blog posts

Beginner's guide on how to choose the right sexy lingerie

Beginner's guide on how to choose the right sexy lingerie

Feeling sexy and beautiful is a right every woman should have - and what better way to ...
Read More
Most Googled Sex Questions

Most Googled Sex Questions

With most people turning to Google to find answers for all of their sexual health relat...
Read More
Everything You Need To Know About Kinks and Fetishes!

Everything You Need To Know About Kinks and Fetishes!

        For our in-store customers, you all know that our Kinky College: BDSM 101 &am...
Read More